"You, the Listener, Are Also Improvising:" An Interview with George E. Lewis

man with glasses on sitting next to a computer
George E. Lewis at IRCAM in Paris, 1984. Photo by Cheryl Lewis.
a group of musicians sitting on the floor in a black and white photo
Musica Elettronica Viva 2, Rome, 1971. Fabrizio Bertuccioli, Paolo Pace, Sandro Bernadoni, Alvin Curran, Yvonne Scholten and Carla Cassola. Photo by Alessandro Figurelli.
an older man sitting, working on the computer
George E. Lewis at IRCAM in Paris, 2025. Photo by Damon Holzborn.
a young boy sitting in front of a massive brass instrument and set of electronic instruments
George E. Lewis in Chicago, 1977. Photo by Nancy Carter.

From November 23 to 25, the American Academy in Rome will host On Improvisation: Sound, Space, Thought, a gathering that brings together international practitioners and thinkers to explore improvisation across disciplines. Part of the 63rd Nuova Consonanza Festival, Tempo, the event also marks the first collaboration between Rome's Nuova Consonanza and New York's International Contemporary Ensemble, under the artistic direction of composer and scholar George E. Lewis, a 2010 Resident and Trustee of the Academy.

Lewis has spent more than five decades exploring the possibilities of improvisation, moving between musical performance, composition, technological experimentation, and scholarship. A composer, trombonist, and musicologist, he has been a member of Chicago's Association for the Advancement of Creative Musicians (AACM) since 1971, an influential collective that challenged established boundaries between composition, improvisation, and artistic collaboration. His landmark book, A Power Stronger Than Itself: The AACM and American Experimental Music, received the American Book Award, while his pioneering work in computer-based music and critical improvisation studies has earned him a MacArthur Fellowship and a Guggenheim Fellowship. He is currently also the Edwin H. Case Professor of American Music at Columbia University and Artistic Director of the International Contemporary Ensemble.

His relationship with Rome also intersects with one of the city's most significant chapters in experimental music. Lewis has collaborated with Musica Elettronica Viva (MEV), the pioneering collective founded in Rome in 1966 by Alvin Curran, Frederic Rzewski, Richard Teitelbaum, and others. Lewis’s subsequent involvement with the group connects him to a generation of musicians who reimagined the relationship between sound, technology, improvisation, and collective creation. Curran, one of the founding figures of MEV and a central presence in Rome's experimental music history, will also participate in the festival's closing-day conversation.

Ahead of this gathering, AAR spoke with Lewis about the artistic and intellectual paths that have shaped his understanding of improvisation, the way the idea of the festival was developed, and what the practice of making music together– without knowing exactly what comes next– might offer our present moment.

The program brings together perspectives from music, philosophy, architecture, and visual arts. What does this interdisciplinary approach allow us to explore about improvisation?

The inspiration for the program is the two-volume Oxford Handbook of Critical Improvisation Studies (2016), co-edited by me and Benjamin Piekut of Cornell University. Both the Handbook and the conference show that improvisation is by no means limited to the arts. 

The Handbook includes contributions from cognitive science, neuroscience, critical and cultural theory, philosophy, dance, theatre, musicology, ethnomusicology, music theory, cultural history, literary history and theory, classical Greek and Roman letters, political science, organizational science, theology, architecture and urban planning, psychology, and computer science.

That kind of breadth of intellectual engagement seemed to be perfect for the Academy.  In fact, Italy is a major site for scholarship on improvisation, and the panel of Italian scholars on the first day, November 23, will be a highlight of the conference.

What all this means for humanity is that, as philosopher Arnold I. Davidson remarked in our 2010 colloquy at the Academy, Improvisation as a Way of Life: Time, Form, Technology, Ethics: “multiplication of perspectives means multiplication of possibilities.”

Improvisation is often associated with spontaneity and freedom. What do you think this understanding overlooks about improvisation and its role in artistic creation?

No artistic practice has a monopoly on freedom, but much of the emphasis on “spontaneity” in improvisation can be traced to the efforts of Western music historians in trying to prove that composition is superior to improvisation, even though the practice of written scores is extremely minoritarian compared to the worldwide ubiquity of musical improvisation.  Artists who wanted to be free of that way of thinking—the composers as ants, the improvisors as grasshoppers, caring only for the moment—reacted by claiming that “spontaneity” was where the real freedom was.

But outside of the arts, scholars and practitioners talking about improvisation in, say, disaster management, don’t care much about the difference between composing and improvising, except to say that “composing” will only get you so far in dealing with a real emergency. Similarly, “planning” cannot eliminate the need for improvisation, because plans can only be created through improvisation. So, the role of improvisation in the arts amounts to the discovery of new freedoms, new pleasures, and new modes of intelligibility.

In a moment so often marked by uncertainty and fragmentation, can improvisation offer a different way of thinking about how we listen, respond to difference, and create together? 

It would be nice to believe that somehow we could use improvisation, that most human and everyday experience, as a tool to somehow save us from ourselves. But improvisation cannot “offer a different way of thinking,” because in fact we as humans are all already improvising, throughout each moment of the waking day. Listening, whether in music or in everyday life, is one of the basic experiences of improvisation in which we deal with uncertainty at every moment, and sometimes fragmentation becomes necessary in unjust environments, where informed debate can unmask false consensus.

It was the philosopher Gilbert Ryle who said that in improvisation you have “ad hockery” plus know-how. Ryle described that simply as a form of thinking. If you aren’t improvising, he said, you’re just acting from habit. So maybe thinking differently means improvising differently--challenging our habits, comfortable assumptions, and outdated narratives, and finding new ways to live and listen.

How did the idea for  "On Improvisation: Sound, Space, Thought " come about? What motivated you to bring this conversation together at this particular moment?

I am a 2010 Resident of the Academy, and I often attend the Academy galas in New York. For the 2024 Gala at Carnegie Hall, Academy President Peter N. Miller entrusted me with the task of curating a performance by the International Contemporary Ensemble of the music of former Academy Fellows in Music Composition.

The program was very well received, and not long after, Peter and I began thinking about how the Ensemble might be brought to Rome. Peter is very keen on interdisciplinary initiatives involving the Academy, and together we developed the idea of a conference on improvisation that would feature scholars working in some of the Academy’s central areas, including visual art, music, and architecture.  The idea took off from there, and Academy curator Ilaria Puri Purini had the great idea of including Nuova Consonanza, one of the world’s most important ensembles for musical experimentalism.

The final concert, D’Improvviso, brings together eighteen musicians from different backgrounds and musical traditions. What does this encounter represent within the larger framework of On Improvisation?

Let me speak directly to the audience here: what I am excited about is hearing musicians making connections, exchanging information, and creating communities through sound. As you listen, you become part of those communities, because you are hearing the music at the same time as the musicians. The musicians literally read each others’ minds through sound, and you can do this too, because you, the listener, are also improvising. Being able to “read minds” lets you understand what the music is saying beyond virtuosity and “new” sounds, even in music that seems unfamiliar at first.  When musicians come together to make music via improvisation, empathy takes center stage. We all hear and feel together, and the only possible mistake in this kind of music is missing the chance to hear something new.    

 

Organized in collaboration with the International Contemporary Ensemble and Nuova Consonanza, as part of the 63rd Festival di Nuova Consonanza, Tempo. With the artistic direction of George E. Lewis (2010 Resident) – Artistic Director of the International Contemporary Ensemble; Ilaria Puri Purini – Executive Director of Galileo Week 2027, Chief Curator, and Acting Heiskell Arts Director of the American Academy in Rome; and Paolo Rotili – President of Nuova Consonanza. Leadership support is provided by Jessie and Charles Price. With the support of Fondazione Musica per Roma. 

Press Inquiries

Maddalena Bonicelli

Rome Press Officer

+39 335 6857707

m.bonicelli.ext [at] aarome.org (m[dot]bonicelli[dot]ext[at]aarome[dot]org)